Download Free Apps & Games @ PHONEKY.com
Download Free Apps & Games @ PHONEKY.com
Subject: Exposing Shi'a lies. Part 3
Replies: 2 Views: 320
mohsin11 4.11.10 - 05:57am
Hadith: Who are those family members, love of which obligated upon us?
It was narrated by Tabarani in al-Kabir, Qatiy in zawaid to Fadail sahaba (1141)
Harb ibn all-Hasan at-Tahhan Hussain al-Ashqar Qays (ibn Rabia) Al-Amash from Said ibn Jubair ibn Abbas: When it was revealed verse No reward do I ask of you for this except the love of those near of kin (42/23), people asked: O messenger of Allah, who are those from your close family members, whose love became incumbent upon us? He answered: Ali, Fatima, and their sons (alaihuma salam). (cited from Fadail) *
mohsin11 4.11.10 - 06:05am
This hadith isn't authentic.
First of all it contradicts to authentic agreed upon narration from ibn Abbas.( http://kawakib.wapgroups.com/topic.asp?tid=134031 See This Article)
Second it contradicts to known history facts. Ali and Fatima (may Allah be pleased with them) married after hijra, and this verse was revealed in Mecca, as said ibn Kathir.
Thirdly this chain is extremely weak. Suyuti noticed its weakness in his commentary
http://al-eman.com/Islamlib/viewchp.asp?BID=248&CID=458s3s3 ''Durr al-Mansur'' *
mohsin11 4.11.10 - 06:10am
1) Harb ibn al-Hasan was weak. See ''Majmau zawaid'' No. 14747
2) Hussain al-Ashqar weak. He was criticized by Bukhari, Abu Zurah, Abu Hatim, Nasai and Daraqutni. (''Mizanul itidal'' 1/531/No. 1986)
3) Qays ibn Rabia was weak. He was discredited by Nasai, Daraqutni, Ahmad and ibn Maeen. (Mizanul itidal 3/393/No. 6910)
4) Al-Amash Sulaiman ibn Mihran was thiqat, but known mudalis, and he narrated this in anana form.
Shaikh Albani said this narration is false in ''Silsila ad-daefa'' (4974) *
